No, Fielding Position Doesn’t Matter and PFPs Need to be Reconsidered
Every once in awhile a random thought pops into your head and makes you think “naw, that can’t be true…can it?”
The other day I caught a tweet about Justin Verlander’s fielding position on his 103rd pitch of the game. That deep into the game JV was still showing signs of high intent, dropping a 99 MPH fastball to freeze the hitter for a backwards K.
What sparked a particular line of thought for me was when Jarod Bayless satirically commented on the pitch that he “could use a better field position.”
It was obvious that Verlander was throwing the pitch with the intent to throw gas, as noticed by the heavy amount of lower half rotation into deceleration, the complete disregard for a fielding position and more obviously by his post game statement “I was really hoping to hit 100 there, but I didn’t quite get it.”
After seeing this tweet, I immediately thought to myself “I wonder how many times Justin Verlander actually fields a ball during the season. He clearly doesn’t care about being in a good fielding position.”
According to Fangraphs, in the 2016 season Justin Verlander made 7 putouts, had 29 assists and made no fielding errors. In his 34 games started, therefore, he had 36 total fielding plays — an average of roughly 1 play per game in 2016.
Looking at that stat on the surface, it seems reasonable to expect coaches to place importance on pitchers fielding their position. I mean you’d want them to be proficient if they have to make a play once a game.
But if you think about this with a little more depth, there are two questions that will surely pop up.
- Should we be coaching pitchers to finish their pitches in a readied fielding position?
- Will performing PFPs make a pitcher better at fielding their position?
If you read the title to this blog post then it should already be apparent what my answers are to these two questions.
Probably not.
Should we be coaching pitchers to finish their pitches in a readied fielding position?
Let’s take a motor control theory perspective on this one. If we follow the thought process that movement is shaped by intention, then why (or how) would we coach a player to both throw the ball at the target AND finish in a fielding position. Though it is possible to successfully pull off a dual intention movement, throwing strikes with high % effort while simultaneously asking a player to control for their end position seems rather difficult. The task of throwing strikes is hard enough as it is for every pitcher, let alone asking them to complete a separate and distinct task.
Moreover, if you are a pitcher throwing with high intent — then this secondary task of ending up in a fielding position may actually be a competing task. If you look at guys who throw with high intent you will see some extravagant follow throughs. As a result pitchers become more rotational, end up pointing towards first base or show off hilarious leg movements.
You can definitely say that none of these would classify as your ideal fielding position.
The idea that intent = velocity as a hard rule is a bit of a contentious claim. There are a number of examples of guys throwing high 90’s with what seems like a more controlled deceleration and great fielding position. This recent Blake Treinen gif comes to mind!
The fact of the matter is that intent does not always equal velocity and vice versa. There are exceptions to the rules.
Regardless of whether or not high ‘intent’ pitching interferes with ending up in a good fielding position, we should return back to the fielding statistics of Justin Verlander for a second.
In 2016, JV was involved in 36 fielding plays in 34 games. Broken down further, that is 36 plays in 3668 pitches! With every pitch that Verlander threw, there was roughly a 1% chance that he was going to make a fielding play. In other words, 99% of the time he didn’t need to be in fielding position.
Are there potentially batted balls that he couldn’t get to because he fell off to the left? Yes. Are there potentially more batted balls that he did get to because he fell off the left? Yes. Is there a signfiicant difference in batted balls that are playable if falling off to the side versus not falling off to the side. I am not sure, but I’d guess probably not. Even if there was, would that more likely bump 1% to 2% or 10%, 20%, 50%?
So whether or not high intent is necessary for velocity or equates to ending up turned towards first base, the chances of that even mattering for JV are 1%. If there’s even a small chance that forcing a pitcher to end in a good fielding position will decrease performance, then it’s not worth trying to correct.
Will performing PFPs make a pitcher better at fielding their position?
In short, the way most people take PFPs, no.
If we surveyed every high school and collegiate program, we’d find that the majority of pitchers practice PFPs in a similar matter. Line up on the mound, go through a dry mechanical rep, and react to and field a predictable softly hit ground ball from the hitting coach. Sometimes coaches get spicey and hit the ball a bit harder or randomly opposite to where they just hit it. Repeat for 15-20 minutes once a week while fielders do something important.
Sound about right?
Let’s break down some issues with this type of practice.
There is a mismatch between the perception-action coupling of the game and that seen in the drill. In a live game, pitchers throw the baseball to a real hitter, then have to make a millisecond movement decision that was not predictable (remember 1%), and also react to the variant in game dynamics of the play. The perceptual information (called affordances) that pitchers are using to make these decisions in a game just aren’t present in the drill. Things like where their body was when releasing the ball, the speed at which they’re moving, the ball’s flight path to the plate, the bat path in reaction to the ball’s location, the handedness of the batter among many others don’t show up in the standard PFP. Am I the only one who has never seen pitchers receive PFP practice from hitters of both handedness?
The affordances here are not the same as what’s encountered in game.
Lack of accounting for pressure. We know that pressure can induce negative movement changes or even result in a player choking. It’s been shown in the literature that players kinematics can freeze up or become rigid as a result of succumbing to pressure. By practicing in an environment devoid of significance or time constraints, we are creating solutions to movement tasks that are fragile and less resilient than if they were practiced in heightened stakes or emotional levels. If we only practice PFPs in a nonchalant manner can we really expect them to be executed in high speed and high stakes? The idea that we need to progressively expose players to pressure situations in order to improve their psychological capacity was detailed further here.
Pitchers need to be infielders… and train like them too. My belief is that asking pitchers to field their position requires them to literally be good fielders. They should have the ability to throw on the run, be accurate from awkward angles, flip balls with their gloves, and be able to properly execute the task ‘get baseball from my hand to a baseman accurately and quickly.’ If we really want to have good fielding pitchers then we need to expose them to many different task dynamics — in other words, shortstop practice for everyone! No seriously, I think pitchers should practice playing other infield positions. Not only does restricting a high school pitcher to PO status crush their ability as throwers (less task dynamics = less movement solutions = less flexible to variant in game demands on the mound) but it also stunts their fielding development.
You can’t practice this play specifically, but you can pratice being a more coordinated fielder…and monotonous, predictable PFPS are not the way to go.
These are just a few of the shortcomings of the standard PFP drill work that I see and there are likely many more.
*One counter argument is that PFP work is more than just fielding a ground ball, but also includes situational plays and position coverage. Yes, that is important to have nailed down, but do we really need to devote any significant time to this? At what age or experience level does positioning on the field become automatic? Or bunt coverage?
In Summary
I believe that if pitchers field 1% of the pitches thrown, then maximizing the effectiveness of each pitch should be their primary focus. If increased awareness of fielding your position is a detriment to this effectiveness, then we have a problem.
If we want pitchers to be better fielders then we need to reconsider the standard PFP. Pitchers should be great infielders before pitching fielders just as they should be great throwers before pitchers.
Производство и поставка – сетка сварная прайс производства Северсталь метиз ОСПАЗ со склада в г.Орел.
Продажа сетка сварная штукатурная оптом и в розницу по низким ценам.
Полный каталог всей метизной продукции, описания, характеристики, ГОСТы и технические условия.
Офоррление заказа и доставка в сжатые сроки. Возможна отгрузка железнодорожным транспортом. Цены производителя.
Производство и поставка – болты гайки шпильки производства Северсталь метиз ОСПАЗ со склада в г.Орел.
Продажа шпильки для крепеления оптом и в розницу по низким ценам.
Полный каталог всей метизной продукции, описания, характеристики, ГОСТы и технические условия.
Офоррление заказа и доставка в сжатые сроки. Возможна отгрузка железнодорожным транспортом. Цены производителя.
Water Damage Mitigation Service centers at helping house dwellers promptly handling water-linked matters.
Service’s key purpose is in order to block more detriment, conserve preservable items, also revive habitability in that home.
Comparable assistance remain often necessary following incidents like water line leaks, torrential downpour, floods, tempests, as well as different weather-related events permitting permit moisture into seep domestic zones.
Imagine a case wherein the plumbing breaks or heavy storm swamps single building, wrecking structures, soaking furniture, and prone to causing mold if ignored.
Rapid step is vital regarding minimise casualties moreover control increasing reconstruction charges. Regarding which ways can the service aid?
Team’s professionals reach rapidly for pump out abundant humidity, fully desiccate such impacted spots, moreover guard such structure preventing infestation spread or more decay.
Fundamentally, our process stabilizes the residence plus guarantees home’s occupancy subsequent to – incident . It dispenses with complete reconstruction nevertheless sets such stage toward later improvements as it averting more acute setbacks later the future.
Get our help right now – 8338561951
Производство и поставка – веревочный канат производства Северсталь, Мечел со склада в г.Орел.
Продажа корабельный канат оптом и в розницу по низким ценам.
Полный каталог всей метизной продукции, описания, характеристики, ГОСТы и технические условия.
Оформление заказа и доставка в сжатые сроки. Возможна отгрузка автотранспортной компанией. Цены от производителя.
Own understand the manner alarming it comes across at the moment moisture sets the residence and relatives’ well-being toward risk.
Still you stay not isolated.
We are available in order to shield their residence as well as this affection relating to yours relatives lifestyle, performing cautiously along with safely such that every single thing you adore persists unbroken.
That crew responds promptly toward block loss plus avoid mildew, bringing somebody peace belonging to consciousness.
And with that 24/7 help, one constantly maintain a person next to their position — set to assist someone maintain one’s kin secure as well as the house enriched by well-being.
Find peace in your home – Call: 8338561951
Myself comprehend the way alarming this strikes when flood sets the property and kin’s security in risk.
However you remain by no means isolated.
We’re around to protect one’s property along with the very affection relating to the household lifestyle, performing cautiously along with safely with the result that all things somebody value stays unbroken.
This staff works promptly aiming to stop harm together with avert growth, providing somebody serenity belonging to spirit.
In addition backed by the 24/7 service, someone always maintain someone beside one’s place — prepared so as to help one protect one’s loved ones safe together with one’s residence full by convenience.
Find peace in your home – Call: 8338561951
Thanks for the post
Picture coming home to find leak spreading through the corners of your home and cherished spaces.
It’s overwhelming — but you don’t need to handle it by yourself.
We’re here to preserve your home and your family’s comfort, working swiftly and safely to limit harm before it spreads. Our team works with respect and caution, restoring not just your property but also your peace of mind.
We help you prevent mold and lasting problems, ensuring a healthier space for your loved ones. And with our day-and-night assistance, you’re always supported through emergencies — we’re just a call away!
Call – 8338561951 and professionals will help you!
You’ve made some really good points there. I looked on the net for more info about the issue and found most individuals will go along with your views on this site.
Thank you a bunch for sharing this with all people
you really realize what you’re talking approximately!
Bookmarked. Please additionally visit my website =).
We can have a hyperlink exchange agreement among us
me know in what way intimidating that comes across whenever moisture puts your home as well as kin’s convenience toward peril.
However you stay hardly isolated.
We are here to protect the house and this kindness belonging to your family lifestyle, operating attentively and harmlessly so the whole one treasure stays secure.
This staff operates promptly in order to stop damage as well as reduce mildew, offering you tranquility of awareness.
Plus backed by that always-on support, one forever get somebody next to yours presence — willing toward assist one maintain the relatives protected and one’s property enriched in comfort.
Find peace in your home – Call: 8338561951
I every time spent my half an hour to read this weblog’s articles or reviews daily along with a mug of coffee.
Excellent post. Keep writing such kind of info on your site.
Im really impressed by it.
Hey there, You have performed a fantastic job. I’ll certainly digg it and in my view recommend to my friends.
I’m sure they’ll be benefited from this site.
I have been exploring for a little bit for any high quality articles or blog
posts on this sort of area . Exploring in Yahoo I eventually stumbled upon this website.
Reading this info So i’m glad to exhibit that I have a very good uncanny
feeling I came upon just what I needed. I most unquestionably will make sure to don?t
fail to remember this site and give it a glance regularly.
Производство и поставка – РёСЃС‚ болт производства Северсталь метиз, Мечел, ММК Метиз, Силур со склада в г.Орел.
Продажа болт din 603 оптом и в розницу по низким ценам.
Полный каталог всей метизной продукции, описания, характеристики, ГОСТы и технические условия.
Оформление заказа и доставка в сжатые сроки. Возможна отгрузка транспортной компанией.
Цены производителя.
Наша компания предлагает сетка тканая с квадратными ячейками производства Северсталь метиз ОСПАЗ со склада
г.Орел. В наличии огромный ассортиментсетка проволочная тканая.
Вы можете купить сетка тканая гост светлую и оцинкованную.
У нас всегда в наличии огромный выбор сетка тканая оцинкованная, цены от производителя.
Продажа сетка тканая стальная оптом и в розницу со склада г.Орел.